You were the one who introduced me to James Taylor,
Dan Fogelberg, and Barry Manilow
I already knew Linda Ronstadt, and you played her songs for me, too
I don't think I ever said it, but
I fell hard... in love with you
Do you remember sitting in your car
Telling scary stories by the railroad tracks
You said your car clock had never worked before that
When it started working by itself
How we hurried out of there, how we laughed
At every stop sign you would stop the car
And give a kiss to me
You would smile while holding my hand
And sing
"She was only sixteen"
You carried me to my first concert
And to church where you played piano and sang
We sang together at a wedding once
"The Lord's Prayer"
And "We've Only Just Begun"
You never knew how much I loved you
I hurt you, and for that I'm deeply sorry to this day
I wish I could go back and make it right
I let you slip away that night
If you had only known how much I cried
After that, we double-dated once
You with a new love
And me with your friend
Though I wished I could trade places with her
I was just happy to get to see you again
It killed me when you kissed her
From the backseat I could see the two of you
But it wasn't the same as we used to be
When you looked at me across the table that night
I wondered if you still had feelings for me
You were my first love
You were the love of my life
And you never knew the truth
That night when I got off the phone with him
I told him I loved you... and to never call me again
I will never forget the memories we made...
My junior/senior prom, your baccalaur'
... another first for me
... the butterflies
And that last Saint Bernard sweatshirt you gave me
One of my biggest regrets I have will forever be
Not explaining that night before you left
After you asked me for your things
And never saying I love you
And telling you then how much you meant to me
You became a teacher with the most beautiful wife and family
I became a teacher, too... a wife and a mother
But once in a while, I think about our love from back then
About the girl I was when I was with you
I'll always remember when I was sixteen
Sometimes I wonder if you ever think about it, too.